Once Madden started leaning heavily into the abilities/xfactors running everything, I stopped playing it. I think it just made the game feel way too over the top and even more arcady than these games already are.
I know some of the abilities on CUT can be annoying at times (take off, Quick jump to be specific. Extender last year too) but I've never felt like you HAVE to run the abilities to be competitive in CUT where as in MUT, if you're not using specific ability stacks, you're at a huge disadvantage and almost don't even have a chance unless you're just incredibly good at the game.
No shade at people who enjoy MUT, it's just not for me anymore.