Who is the best qb so far?

Ive been seeing a lot of hype for Brady Cook lately but havent used him myself.

I love Vick, but I know who isnt the best, and that’s Kyler Murray. 
Poor guy is so short he’s throwing off lineman’s helmets….getting balls tipped.

People always bring speed up eith a qb but yet in all the games I've played,  i rarely ever play anyone that runs with qb. I've used a lot of qbs and here's my list 

1. Cook

2. Ewers

3. Vick

4. Newton

5  Brady 

But everyone plays different so who's good for me, may not be good for you.

Best I've used in this order are

Cook

Booty

Burrow

I basically stay in the pocket, so I never had much fun with Vic or Cam

Sold my Brady for Jennings and I have no regrets

it so crazy because every qb in this game has frustrating elements, I think a cam ward that eventually comes out will be qb1, his release is so nice, but rn I gotta say Cook can throw dots, toughness is just so low. I hate Newton’s throw under pressure, and then vick looks like a modern day running back and he is left handed which is a major no no in this game. I run oregon playbook so Troy smith with 97 thp was nice, But Cook is technically the best and I hate that is the case. Mariota, Charlie Ward, Vince, and Braxton played so smooth when they came out. Now every quarterback has been meh for their own reasons

cc85 said:

Booty.  He’s 6’3 and takes a hit when running draws or Blasts up the middle with very few fumbles. Has Dot!  too.   
 

the Best QB will be the one that completes your Offense scheme.  Getting 50/50 chemistry is more important than many realize.

I've been rocking Booty since pulling him BND around Christmas and he's been amazing! I use the bama playbook. I run a lot of QB design runs and screens. Booty opened the RPO playbook for me. He's also got really good Play Action and solid throw on the run. Haven't played with Scam but I'm sure he plays like a poor man's Scam. 

I have 50/50 UGA TT. I was really excited about the Hines Ward release. Saw the attributes/traits and was underwhelmed. Played a couple squads yesterday who were using Hines and was not impressed. Maybe we'll get a Stafford soon with 97+ throw power?

carson11 said:

everyone having a different answer here makes me so happy

same lol part of why this is formatted to be way better than madden (imo)

I still use Money Manziel (benched BND Vick after two games). Manziel has workhorse, clutch traits, and decent speed. Nobody I have encountered has been worth the coin to move on from him. One of his downsides is that he only has three ability slots instead of the newer 4

beauregardfh said:

I still use Money Manziel (benched BND Vick after two games). Manziel has workhorse, clutch traits, and decent speed. Nobody I have encountered has been worth the coin to move on from him. One of his downsides is that he only has three ability slots instead of the newer 4

And has the tight spiral trait

One QB that seems to be slept on is Jaxson Dart. I've been using him since I pulled him BND during Christmas Rush and he has been by far my favorite QB (besides maybe the Brady Cook card, but I didn't have him BND, so no reason to keep him for the price). 

Dart has enough speed to move around, has top end short and mid accuracy (both 97 stock), good deep accuracy, good throw power, and has a pretty quick release (feels similar to Cam Ward). The only knock I could see would be that he doesn't get Silver Dot, but I haven't had any issues with him not having that ability and I play on Placement only. He also doesn't get Workhorse, but I don't run with my QB much, so that's not an issue.

GoIrish1977 said:

People will laugh but….The 91 Burrow is the best. Can make all the throws but also has not fumbled ONCE since I got him. I quit sliding, It’s insane lol

I believe it, I was using him for the longest time. Now I’m using 92 Carson Beck, I’ve tried Vick and Cook but have always gone back to Beck. I may have to go back to Burrow though, Beck fumbles if someone breathes on him lol.